Comparing Titans of Trenchless Technology: Ditch Witch JT3020 and Vermeer D36X50 - A Detailed info
Comparing the Ditch Witch JT3020 Mach 1 and Vermeer D36X50:
1. Manufacturer and Model:
- Ditch Witch JT3020 Mach 1: Manufactured by Ditch Witch.
- Vermeer D36X50: Manufactured by Vermeer.
2. Rig Size and Pullback:
- JT3020: Rig size is in the 20,001 - 30,000 lbs pullback range.
- D36X50: Rig size falls in the 30,001 - 50,000 lbs pullback category, indicating a potentially larger and more powerful machine.
3. Engine and Power:
- JT3020: Equipped with a Cummins QSB4.5 engine, delivering 148 hp (110 kW), peaking at 156 hp (116 kW) at 2000 rpm.
- D36X50: Powered by a John Deere 4045H engine with 125 hp (93.2 kW).
- JT3020: Overall length of 219.3 inches, width of 79.4 inches, and height of 114.5 inches. Operating weight is 21,660 lb.
- D36X50: Length of 272 inches (for the 15 ft drill unit), width of 82 inches, and height of 83 inches. Weight is 21,920 lb for the 15 ft drill unit.
- JT3020: Max spindle speed of 225 rpm, max torque of 4000 ft/lb, thrust force of 24,800 lb, and pullback force of 30,000 lb.
- D36X50: Max spindle speed of 227 rpm, max torque of 4995 ft/lb, and both thrust and pullback force at 36,000 lbs.
6. Drilling Capabilities:
- JT3020: Minimum bore diameter of 4.5 inches, with a minimum bend radius of 175 feet.
- D36X50: Minimum bore diameter of 3.5 inches, with a min bend radius of 145.5 feet for the 15 ft drill unit.
7. Fuel and Hydraulic Capacity:
- JT3020: Fuel tank capacity is 42 gallons, and hydraulic tank capacity is 27 gallons.
- D36X50: Fuel tank holds 29 gallons (15 ft drill unit), and hydraulic tank has a capacity of 55 gallons.
8. Drilling Fluid System:
- Both machines have a maximum drilling fluid flow of 50 gpm and a max pressure of 1500 psi for the JT3020 and 1300 psi for the D36X50.
In summary, the Vermeer D36X50 appears to be slightly larger and more powerful in terms of pullback and torque capacity. It also has a larger hydraulic tank capacity. The Ditch Witch JT3020, on the other hand, offers a slightly higher engine power and fuel tank capacity. The choice between the two would depend on the specific needs of the project, considering factors like power requirements, size constraints, and fuel efficiency [oai_citation:1,Equipment Specifications for a Ditch Witch JT3020 Mach 1](https://www.hddbroker.com/en/resources/equipmentlibrary/viewmodel.php?id=1199) [oai_citation:2,Equipment Specifications for a Vermeer D36x50](https://www.hddbroker.com/en/resources/equipmentlibrary/viewmodel.php?id=876).
I searched the web for customer reviews about Ditch Witch JT3020 and Vermeer D36X50, two models of horizontal directional drills. Here is what I found:
The Ditch Witch JT3020 is praised for its high torque and thrust/pullback capability, compact design and maneuverability, making it suitable for tight and hard-to-reach drilling locations1. It also has a large capacity pipe lubrication system and a high fluid flow for longer installations and when working in sandy soil1. Some customers also like its operator’s station, fluid pump, and rack1.
The Vermeer D36X50 is renowned for its reliability, versatility and class-leading power-to-size ratio2. It has a Tier 3 or Tier 4i 140 hp John Deere PowerTech engine, which provides 36,000 lb of thrust/pullback force and 4995 ft-lb of torque2. It also offers two-gear mount, electric shock reporting system, and hydraulic linkage changing system as special equipment3. Some customers consider it to be "the Ferrari of directional drills"4.